Oldest City Insurance Oldest City Insurance (904) 824-7283 212 San Marco Avenue, Suite DSt. Augustine, FL 32084 View Google Map Share This Oldest City Insurance (904) 824-7283 212 San Marco Avenue, Suite DSt. Augustine, FL 32084 Share This Profile Keywords North CityRestaurants nearby El Potro Mexican Restaurant0.1 miles Hazel's Hot Dogs0.1 miles Drake's Bistro0.2 miles Maison Louis Café0.2 milesRequest Visitor InformationRequest St. Augustine FREE information, direct to your inbox.Request Information